Why Bohm ' S Quantum Theory ?
نویسندگان
چکیده
In his recent article on "Quantum theory without observers" [1], Sheldon Goldstein raised a number of important questions about quantum theory. Even though I cannot quite understand what a universal physical theory without any concept of observers could mean, I agree with many of his critical remarks. Bell, who once objected "against measurement," also pointed out that Bohm's quantum theory depends on the assumption that only its hypothetical classical variables can directly affect the consciousness of an observer |2]. However, Goldstein's characterization of the consequences that have to be drawn from his criticism appears one-sided, since he neglects many essential aspects. In particular, he does not mention at all that Bohm's classical trajectories can neither be experimentally confirmed nor refuted if the theory is exactly valid. It is always possible to postulate otherwise unobservable (hence arbitrary) causes for stochastic events. Bohm's presumed ensemble of classical configurations is merely dynamically consistent because of their presumed unobservable dynam-
منابع مشابه
اثرات ناخالصیهای مغناطیسی بر عبور الکترون از یک نانو حلقه کوانتومی
In this paper we study the Aharonov-Bohm oscillations of transmission coefficient for an electron passing through a quantum nanoring with two identical magnetic impurities using quantum waveguide theory. It is shown that the Aharonov-Bohm oscillations are independent of the coupling constant between the electron and magnetic impurities for the singlet spin state of impurities, while for the o...
متن کاملFrom the Heisenberg Picture to Bohm: a New Perspective on Active Information and its relation to Shannon Information
In this paper we discuss some of the background to the notion of active information introduced by Bohm and Hiley to account for quantum processes. To appreciate the full significance of this new notion, we show why it is essential to distinguish our approach from the approach that goes under the name 'Bohmian mechanics'. We then show for the first time how the quantum potential emerges from the...
متن کاملAn Experiment to Distinguish Between de Broglie-Bohm and Standard Quantum Mechanics
An experiment is suggested that is capable of distinguishing between the de Broglie-Bohm theory and standard quantum mechanics.
متن کاملEffects of on-center impurity on energy levels of low-lying states in concentric double quantum rings
In this paper, the electronic eigenstates and energy spectra of single and two-interacting electrons confined in a concentric double quantum rings with a perpendicular magnetic field in the presence of on-center donor and acceptor impurities are calculated using the exact diagonalization method. For a single electron case, the binding energy of on-center donor and acceptor impurities ar...
متن کاملEffects of on-center impurity on energy levels of low-lying states in concentric double quantum rings
In this paper, the electronic eigenstates and energy spectra of single and two-interacting electrons confined in a concentric double quantum rings with a perpendicular magnetic field in the presence of on-center donor and acceptor impurities are calculated using the exact diagonalization method. For a single electron case, the binding energy of on-center donor and acceptor impurities ar...
متن کامل